What happened to Amy Carnevale? On August 23rd, 1991 14-year-old Amy went to give her ex boyfriend, Jamie Fuller, a haircut but when she didn’t return home her family started to worry about her. Jamie said that he didn’t know where Amy was and joined her family to help search for her. But after days went by and Amy was still missing, a 19-year-old boy came forward with some chilling information about where Amy was and who Jamie truly was. This confession truly shocked police and the public because apparently, Amy’s murder had been planned for over a year… So what happened to Amy Carnevale? Jackie: IG / TikTok Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices